Wednesday, January 27, 2016

Chapter One: Better Broccoli

I say, “Broccoli,” you say “Ick.” I say, “Broccoli,” you say “Ick.” Am I right? Everyone hates broccoli, it’s disgusting.  It’s little green trees of disgustingness and everyone hates it...and if you, in fact, like it that is simply because you are a weird freak and have been brainwashed.  These are facts.  Pure, simple, truth.  Truth that I am courageously willing to speak out about (stop, stop, I’m no hero, just a man who cares).

I’ll be honest, from time to time I will be spreading the good cheer of my broc-o-hatred and some rejected prophet from the land of misfit vegetables will preach another gospel.  “But if you have it with cheese it’s delicious!” they’ll say. No. It’s not. Cheese is delicious.  Broccoli is broccoli.  Don’t get it twisted.  I could melt cheese on the hot pavement outside my house and proceed to lick it up.  That cheese would, in fact, taste good, but no one in their right mind would claim this means we should eat pavement.  As I have made clear: broccoli, that food cursed in the fall, is gross.

Now I realize that these first two paragraphs may seem rather disconnected from who we are and what we do as the church in 21st century America.  But not really as far as you think.  

Let me draw the parallel for you:  I don’t like broccoli, most of the culture doesn’t like church.  Now how much experience I have with broccoli, or the culture has with the church is not the point, the point is simply that these are deeply entrenched views.  Views that are so entrenched that they are unlikely to change.  The fact that they are entrenched poses a problem for those of us who follow Jesus, and feel called to bid others to do that same.

The problem is this, we are in the role of trying to sell something to people that they at the very least are indifferent towards or perhaps worse have a certain animosity towards.  The result is often almost exactly like what would happen if you came to me and tried to sell me on better broccoli.

Imagine that you came to me and breathlessly proclaimed that you, and you alone,  made the best broccoli in the world! Your broccoli was amazing, it was, as they say, “Not your mother’s broccoli” or “broccoli like  you’ve never had it before.” I will tell you right now what would happen:  If I don’t know you well, I might nod and be polite...but I am still not eating your broccoli.  If I know you very well, I am going to laugh at you, mock you and knock the broccoli out of your hands, so no one has to eat it, because it’s broccoli and hey that is how I roll.  In either case, I will tell you what I am not going to do: eat your broccoli.  I am not going to have a light bulb appear over my head, or a light dawn from heaven.  I am not going to fall at your feet and thank you for delivering your broccoli in such a way that I finally realized that, wow, instead of medium rare ribeye, stringy green slimy mini vegetable trees were the true desire of my heart.  Because here is a bedrock fact: I do not like broccoli.  And when I say that I say it with full awareness that some people make broccoli with cheese, or bacon (mmmmm bacon) or all kinds of broccoli snazzing up additions.  They way you make the broccoli is not the issue, it's the broccoli.  

It is my observation that the way we promote the church assumes that it is the package that is the issue. It’s not. I know that you have been told by book after book after book that if you could simply change this or change that about the way you do church everything would be ok and your church would have such expansive revival that in the future they would write about you in history books, or at least on Wikipedia.  While it is true that there are still places where the style of church is inhibiting growth, (and those folks should definitely change), I don’t think that I am going out on to big of a limb to say that in most places that is no longer the case. Nor am I over reaching to say that the various factors contributing to America becoming a post-Christian culture will accelerate making it even more unlikely that style with be the key factor keeping your church from growth.  The simple reality is that fewer and fewer people are going to church in America.  A good number of these folks are completely unchurched, i.e. they have never been a part of a church and see very little compelling reason to be a part of any congregation.  For those people, any church, or any style is going to be strange and foreign.  If you think somehow that to an unchurched American male that singing contemporary songs out loud with other men is somehow less strange than singing out loud with other men to an organ, you have not been around enough unchurched men.  It is true that one may make the man feel like he is on an episode of Downton Abby, but is that really significantly different than feeling like you are a cast member of Glee?  For the dechurched (always the most likely group to be impacted by stylistic changes and marketing) we need to face the fact that the church growth movement, which contributed to massive stylistic changes in the church is now 48 years old, we also need to face the fact that Willow Creek, the granddaddy of “attractional” churches is over 30 years old, the impact of these two movements has been felt in virtually every corner of the church world.  What that means is this: going forward the majority of those who are “dechurched” will have become “dechurched” not from “Our daddy’s church” or because they have never experienced “a Church like they have never seen before” with a rocking band and a come as you are ethos... but in fact they will be dechurched from exactly that.  It’s been 30 years, they have come, they have seen, they have left and a better church is not bringing them back.  Whether unchurched or dechurched, its not the package, its the church, and no matter how we advertise it or snazz it up, it’s still broccoli and all the cheese in the world is not going to change their minds.

So should we give up?  No! The constant theme you will find running through these pages is mission.  Mission is never far from our minds, we view it as central to the calling of every believer in every age.  Missions is not the end, praise of Jesus is.  Our unified testimony is that Jesus deserves worship and glory and honor and as such he has given us for this temporary lifetime the assignment of being sent to the corners of the earth to round up people to worship him.  This is an awesome responsibility, but we hope to be up to the task, for Jesus’ glory and mankind's joy.  It is up to every generation to discover how to faithfully carry out that mission in its own time and place.  As such what you read here will be a slight critique of many of the methods of mission presented to us in our American megachurch culture.  But we hope that this will not be read as simply a critique but rather we hope that in these pages regular guys will be encouraged that we really do have a messages that is much more desirable than the best “Broccoli,”  and that God has given each of us the means and ability to be a part of that mission. These pages will primarily document the ways in which two guys you have probably never hear of do church ever mindful of that mission.   We will cover topics like community, discipleship, the ability to throw a good party and church planting and will attempt to show that being faithful for the kingdom of God and having an impact is not limited to only the most gifted, or best financed, but rather you and everyone else most people have never heard can have a life and ministry of significance.  We hope at the end of the day you will be encouraged and inspired to join God in his mission--

No comments:

Post a Comment