Tuesday, July 5, 2016

Brown vs. Board of Education, Segregation and Two Americas

Sometimes it creeps in in ways you would not expect, its subtle but it’s there.  The realization that even though there is only one geography, there are in fact many Americas. In the case I am thinking of, I suppose it wasn’t all that subtle, but came on me as a sudden realization, and when it had thus dawned on me the weight of it hit me like a ton of bricks.

We were all sitting “criss-cross applesauce” at the feet of a docent at the local museum.  The occasion was a great program called Immerse where fifth grade classes come to the museum to do school for a week of hands-on learning.  At the moment in question, we were sitting in the shadow of an exhibit on immigration and the settling of our city as well as the coming of the civil rights movement.  Now I am sure that our very skilled presenter had done this talk many, many times...I suspect however she had not done it as much for a class like ours, mostly hispanic and black.  The canned presentation, which I am sure worked wonderfully for the majority white classes she was probably used to seeing, was borderline humorous when presented to a class made up of ethnic minorities and actual recent immigrants.  The moment that sticks in my mind is when she looked at a young black boy and said, in reference to Brown Vs Board of Education, something like “and this was so good because before that the schools were segregated and you would not have been to go to a school with white students…” This she said triumphantly and without the trace of irony that should have been present.   There are two white kids in this class, only one, my own, had the option of being anywhere else.  Two white kids, and 30 black and brown faces listening as the virtues of integrated education were extolled.  In her America I am sure this seems true, in the other America the waiting continues for Brown Vs. Board of education to be implemented.

Brown vs. Board of Education, striking down Plessy vs Ferguson and its years of “separate but equal,” was decided in 1954.  Under Ferguson the schools, while segregated, were to provide equal education, in reality they did anything but. “At the time southern black schools received only 60 percent of the per-pupil funding as southern white schools, up from 45 percent in 1940. Many southern black schools therefore lacked such basic necessities as cafeterias, libraries, gymnasiums, running water and electricity.” The decision of the court was of course good news for our country.  Yet not all was perfect. The court ruled against segregation, but gave no guidance on how to implement its end.  While the Justice Department filed a brief on behalf of ending segregation, Dwight Eisenhower was less supportive, telling Chief Justice Earl Warren before the case was decided that southern whites were “...not bad people.”  The States for their part actively worked to keep the schools segregated, with Alabama Governor George Wallace famously crying out in 1963, “Segregation now! Segregation tomorrow! Segregation forever!” Ten years later in 1964 “only about 1 percent of black children in the former Confederacy attended school with whites, and those who did often endured constant harassment.” Also telling is that from the years 1961-1971 the enrollment in non-Catholic private schools doubled, perhaps not solely because of a fear of integration, but it was certainly a large factor.  The cropping up of new Christian schools during this era earned them the moniker “Segregation Academies.” The reality is that well into the 1970’s the fight to integrate America's schools was still waging.

This background is necessary so that I can say this: Brown Vs. Education struck down segregation in 1954 but was not implemented for decades and we have been very effectively doing all we can to nullify it in America ever since.  Consider that as we sit today, in the year 2016, schools are more segregated than they have been since 1980, only 26 years after Brown, and within a decade of the strongest attempts made to fully implement the order.  

It is time for us to ask honestly why?  Why are our schools still so segregated? What are many 94 percent White and why are others 94 percent black?  We also need to ask why does there continue to be an achievement gap between those two schools?  What is keeping us from integrating schools? Why have we poured on law after law that blunts the effects of Brown? (Such as the federal law that makes it illegal to consider race when drawing the boundary lines of any school district.)

The answer whether we like it or not is racism.  I know that is where many feared I would go...but won’t we all feel better if we stop lying to ourselves?  Racism is the only logical answer.  One might wisely say, “it's not about race it is about income!”  Which, when the socioeconomic status of the majority of people in a majority minority school is considered, does make sense.  But then one must ask why is that that people of color are so disproportionately represented in the impoverished class? Poverty is a correlating factor, but we must stop and ask what is causing that poverty.  We must either agree that: There are systematic factors contributing to a disadvantage for people of color which is an acknowledgement of systematic racism or say that the people of color themselves are more prone to poverty, they are not as smart, hardworking, family oriented etc., which would be an example of personal racism.  There does not seem to be a way forward unless we acknowledge the role of race.  

Now one thing I feel needs to be said is this, to acknowledge that race plays a role is not the same as saying “I am a racist,” I think one of the things holding the conversation about race back in this country is that white people, and especially evangelical white people, hold to a generally individualistic view of the world, this is true of most of our cultural and even of how we have taught much of theology in evangelical circles (with our emphasis on “personal relationships” with Jesus).  When we begin to talk about racism, because white folks tend to be individualistic, we tend to hear the issue as “You personally harbor deep seated individual prejudice in your heart,” thus the much maligned response “I’m not racist , I have black friends,” which to a person who does not think in systems makes perfect sense. The problem here is that if we do not begin to think in terms of the system, we have no answer for why in 2016 people of color are disproportionately impoverished and how that is resulting in the complete overthrow of Brown Vs. Board of Education.  While I would suggest that to greater or lesser extent all people harbor some form of individual prejudice, the problem we need to confront at this time is a system that producing exactly what it is designed to produce: injustice. Specifically the injustice of higher poverty leading to a greater number of people of color attending schools that are under resourced and de-facto segregated.

When I teach on the reality of systematic racism/injustice sometimes called white privilege one thing I try and make clear is that it is not always a matter of hate/prejudice/intent but simply a matter of mathematics.  If caucasians are the majority in this country, and they are, then it would stand to reason that they also fill the majority of management positions in this country.  It would also stand to reason that given the current segregated state of schools, churches and other social organizations in this country that the majority of the people in their lives are also white. So when the white manager, from the white majority goes to hire for any given position it also stands to reason that his applicant pool is most often drawn from his own culture or circle of influence and is also going to be majority white.  This is not due to overt prejudice on his part but simply a function of math and how the American system works.  When jobs open up, when references and referrals are needed there is a simple numeric advantage to being a caucasian.  This is also where the system becomes circular, because the system disadvantages those with the least connections to people in the hiring/promoting class, people in that class are less likely to be hired or to receive promotions, making them more likely to be economically disadvantaged, making them more likely to attend schools in economically disadvantaged neighborhoods, making those schools less likely to be integrated and thus continuing the same problems in further generations.   

There are amazing schools doing an amazing job of educating in high-poverty neighborhoods, I’m on the board of one and my wife works for another, but let us not be so ignorant and silly as to pretend that educating students in poverty is no more difficult and contains no greater challenges than educating students from wealth or students from diverse economic populations.  It certainly does and yet from a government perspective we have done little to address these issues, ironically the only thing that is treated as equal is the presumed level of advantage.  Meaning that even though everyone understands that there is a vast difference in educating students from poverty and students not in poverty, we act from a policy standpoint as if they were the same and there was no advantage or deficit to either one.   

It is time to look at our schools and be honest about the fact that Brown Vs. Board of Education is simply a historical pipedream that to date has not been realized in this country, and until it is realized and children of every color receive a truly equitable education we will never be able to “move past” race, as so many from the majority culture seem to desire.  It is time to acknowledge that 400 years of legal discrimination was not followed by completely changed hearts on the day Brown Vs. Board of Ed was signed, nor on July 2, 1964 when the Civil Rights Act was signed, and not even the next year in 1965 when the Voters Rights Act was signed.  These were all legal progress but none of them had the power to change the human heart, and the heart of America has remained extremely sick on the issue of race to this day.  We live still in a odd country where people lose their mind over a black Annie, a black storm trooper and any insinuation that racism exists.  How can this be?  It is an extremely shortsighted view of both history and the human heart to assume that 300 years of slavery followed by 100 years of legal discrimination, followed by decades long fights to keep from implementing Brown Vs. Board of Education has been completely remedied without any lingering, systematic effects in what essentially amounts to 30 years.  

I read once that the bombing of the church in Birmingham, which killed four African American girls, was a turning point for whites in the civil rights movement. This act forced whites, who up until that time felt the movement a nuisance they would rather ignore, to decide exactly whose side they wanted to be on, and for most of them siding with church bombers was not an option.  I feel like we, in the majority culture, face a similar issue in the year 2016, we need to decide which side were will be on.  Have you seen what is happening is Detroit Public Schools?  Do you really believe that would happen in your schools? Have you seen how government ineptitude poisoned that water supply in Flint? There may not have been a bomb, but should we be less outraged that our country’s children are being killed slowly?  Let us say that enough is enough, that race is an issue in our country, that systematic racism exists and it’s horrifying effects are being felt and multiplied especially in our schools.  Let us not be blind to the irony of preaching the good news of Brown Vs. Board of Education to a classroom full of students in a segregated school.  Let us realize that the “greatness” of America, is often limited to people in certain Americas, and that America is a country many of our fellow citizens have not even been allowed to visit.  It is time to choose, either the system is racist or your are.

We must always take sides. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented.- Elie Wiesel  

If you would like the footnoted version click here

No comments:

Post a Comment